Saturday, February 7, 2009

Which One? RAK

Last night I did a Christmas LO and wasn't overly happy with it ... this morning I pulled it apart and made a change ... Which one do you like best?
Leave a comment and I'll enter you into a RAK for some chipboard Alphas ...


31 comments:

interactthis said...

Id o that too - have to rework a LO that just isn't doing it for me. I think the second LO is better too. Good work and thanks for sharing! Fellow Fiskateer Chris #5011

Barb - Fiskateer #2975 said...

Gotta say I like the 2nd one better - the dots on the background of the first take away from the photos!

maryanneh said...

like em both but really love the 2nd one #5271

Karin D said...

They are both nice - but I have to say I prefer the 2nd one. The dots make the LO very busy and take away from your pictures.

Fiskateer# 4472

marla said...

I agree the second one is better because the dot background paper takes away from the photos and makes it too busy. #3291

fromtheowlsnest said...

have to agree with everyone else and let you know that the second one compliments your photos so much better......sometimes it takes a second look!!!!

fromtheowlsnest said...

whoopsie....forgot....Sharon #4066

Jennie said...

even though i liked the first one so much, seeing the LO with plan backround i have to say i like it better!

Chelle said...

i agree with everyone else. the pictures are easier to see on the second one. Chelle #4460

Kristin in OH said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kristin in OH said...

I vote for the second one. Great LO! I am reposting this one because I forgot to post my Fiskateer #...Kristin in OH #2764

pattyb said...

They are both actually very good...but forced to choose I would say the second.

Fiskateer 2262

Ziggyeor said...

I like the second LO the background isn't so busy and you can see the pictures :D

Ziggyeor Fiskateer #4823

Jen said...

I would have to say although they are both great...I like the updated one better!!! WTG lookin' good :)

~jen~
3213

kristine said...

im shocking at ripping aprt layouts im not happy with, i do prefer the second layout as the dots dont distract from the photos

Turtlelady~Sandy said...

I like the dots background :=)

rayasunshine said...

I like the dots background. How nice to be so warm at the holidays!!
Cicly #1835

Turtlelady~Sandy said...

Sorry, forgot my #1715, Turtlelady :=)

Tona said...

I like the 2nd one the best. A very nice layout!
#4437

javawava said...

I like the zoo one. The top one is good, but the dots are a bit distracting. Good job!
Sandy Fiskateer #1598

Sondra said...

The second one is better I think. BarefootProf@bellsouth.net Fiskateer #4936

Rosemary said...

I like the second one the best. Nice job! Rosemary (rosemarypike@aol.com Fiskateer #5576)

Kelly said...

I agree with the majority here and go for the second layout as yes it doesnt look too busy and you see all the details in the pictures at first glance
Kelly Muir #1014

Kimberly Hellams said...

I like the first one listed which I think is the second LO you did.

Kimberly2335@aol.com
Fiskateer #5277

Karee Sue said...

I have to pick the second one too, the first is way to busy, good job though, it turned out really well.
I think we all do that from time to time, choose the wrong paper and have to rework.
fiskateer #3609

RosyGlow said...

I like the second l/o much better. The dots were too distracting from the photos. I love the placement of your pics in the l/o.
Fiskateer 5614

Mardi said...

I love the 2nd one! Wow I have never done this before, once I get it scrapped it is done! You go girl!

Laura1943 said...

LOVE the new one ! The first one...the polka dots were just too distracting...The new one focuses on your pics much nicer !

Donna said...

I really like how you used the circles,the solid background really makes them pop. Your work is beautiful!

Lisa's Scrap Site said...

I left comment on Fiskar Board,#5095

Heidi Y said...

I really like the 2nd LO - the first one looked a little busy with the Polka-dots. - Heidi#1841